One of the things that really irk me is when somebody tries to point out (no matter how pointless it may be) that religion-- Christianity in particular-- only wants this world to end. That religious persons always point out how worthless life on Earth can be, how sinful human beings have become since the dawn of Adam and Eve, and that the only way for Christians to save this world is to pray to God "Thy Kingdom come..." and believe in God's Son who became a sacrifice to satisfy the injured honor of God when Adam and Eve chose to eat the fruit of a forbidden tree.
I do not understand the outburst of Naturalist Atheists when they themselves admit that everything on Earth IS DOOMED TO EXTINCTION (Bertrandt Russell). And if the propositions of Atheists are true, that everything on Earth is a product of collocations of Atoms, and we human beings are nothing more but "complex chunks of matter", and that everything we feel and believe in is nothing more but chemical reactions in our brains (Richard Dawkins), and that what we know today is nothing more but a product of genetical impulse to survive (Daniel Dennett), then any person with a rational mind is not rational since: 1. We are dying anyway. 2. We are dying anyway because we are mere chunks of matter. 3. What we believe or know to be true is just a tool for us to survive so we can prolong our lives before dying. Folks, all of these will only make sense if we take the world AS not only a dying world BUT also a hopeless world. I do not see, then, WHAT'S WRONG in wishing for the world like this to end abruptly.
(Atheism: The religious belief in a spontaneous, causeless, sourceless, purposeless, meaningless existence.)
Atheists must know that NOT ALL religions are pro-death. Not Christianity. Not Orthodox Christianity.
Let me go back to the three accusations of Naturalist Atheists, telling that Christianity's eschatology is synonymous with pro-death:
1. Christians would like this world to end because human beings are born sinners and that we are always inclined to do sinful things.
2. Since humans are born sinners, nothing good will ever come out of us, said the Christians, hence the disarrayed state of the world.
3. Since we are evil to the core, having chosen to disobey God, we became God's enemies. Thus God's wrath is upon us, said the Christians.
MISCONCEPTIONS OF ATHEISM'S SWEEPING STATEMENT: THE DOCTRINE OF ORIGINAL SIN AND SATISFACTION THEORY OF ATONEMENT
When Rome separated itself from the Conciliar Pentarchy of the Orthodox Church, declaring herself to be universal pontiff, this Schism produced wide and varying heterodoxies (heresies) unknown to the heresies the Orthodox Church fought against. The errors of Rome produced, I believe, the two most famous heresies: The Doctrine of Original Sin and The Satisfaction Theory of Atonement.
The Doctrine of Original Sin was conceived by Blessed Augustine of Hippo, Bishop of Alexandria. Centuries later, toward Medieval times, spawned from Original Sin doctrine, was the The Satisfaction Theory of Atonement, formulated by St. Anselm Bishop of Canterbury, England.
The Original Sin came about after Augustine read the misrepresentation of St. Jerome (Augustine and Jerome are both Western Theologians. Western Theology is the collective term for Roman Catholic and Protestant theologies.), regarding Romans 5:12. Augustine read this verse without the lens of the Orthodox Church Fathers.
In all fairness, Augustine and the rest of Rome, after the Schism, no longer understood Greek ( the language of the Eastern Fathers), so it is possible that he had never heard of St. john Chrysostom's teachings on Ancestral Sin. And so did Anselm of Canterbury.
Here is what Chrysostom taught:
Chrysostom, while claiming that all human beings are made in the image of God, believed that the Ancestral Sin brought corruptibility and death not only to Adam but to all his descendants, weakening his ability to grow into God’s likeness, but never destroying God’s image (free will). Chrysostom is a major voice within a consensus of Greek patristic writers who interpret the Fall as “an inheritance essentially of mortality rather than sinfulness, sinfulness being merely a consequence of mortality”.[ii] Chrysostom’s position is echoed, for example, by St Athanasius the Great and St Cyril of Alexandria, who claimed that we are not guilty of Adam’s sin, though we inherit a corrupted nature; but our free will remains in tact. This Greek patristic interpretation is founded upon Romans 5:12: “As sin came into the world through one man, and through sin, death, so death spread to all men because all men have sinned”. John Meyendorff explains how the deficient Latin translation of the text may have contributed to such a stark difference in the Latin interpretation of the Ancestral Sin: ‘In this passage there is a major issue of translation. The last four Greek words were translated in Latin as in quo omnes peccaverunt (“in whom [i.e., in Adam] all men have sinned”), and this translation was used in the West to justify the guilt inherited from Adam and spread to his descendants. But such a meaning cannot be drawn from the original Greek’.[iii] (1)
Thus, he (Augustine) concluded that not only did human beings inherited sin, we also inherited the guilt of Adam and Eve. He went as far as to conclude that because of this, humans are born totally depraved and therefore incapable of deciding and doing anything good apart from God.
Fast forward to middle ages when scholasticism produced and retained great western thoughts. In these times lived St. Anselm of Canterbury, a Roman Catholic in England. Of course he would study the greatest minds of Western Theology including that of St. Jerome and Augustine. With the long stretch of Schism between the Eastern Orthodox and Rome, very few, if any, Eastern thought penetrated the West. To cut the story short, Anselm developed Satisfaction theory of Atonement. Its bedrock was Augustine's Original Sin.
Here's why.
According to this theory of atonement, since Adam and Eve consciously disobeyed God, every human being throughout history inherited the sin and guilt of these forebears. By the virtue of birth, a human being is utterly marred (I'm using Calvin's term here) by this Original Sin thus separated from God at birth. (Hence, the practice of infant Baptism by Roman Catholics and some Protestants.) By contrast, the Orthodox Church baptizes babies not because of Original Sin, but because the Children are now welcomed and dedicated to Orthodoxy and God. We Orthodox do not call it Original Sin, but Ancestral Sin-- humans inherit the EFFECTS of what Adam and Eve did, NOT the sin and guilt that Adam and Eve committed and had.
Since, human beings are separated from God at birth, that separation earns a person the wrath of God (Bear in mind that in this theory, human beings had become God's enemies). And therefore he could never escape God's judgment. God's solution? Since, according to this theory, humans have 1. inherited the sin and guilt of Adam and Eve, 2. become sinners at birth 3. earned God's wrath from the day humans were born, therefore, SOMEONE has to pay the price to appease God and restore humans' communion with Him. And that was Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ had to die on the cross so God's wrath wouldn't be upon humans but on Christ alone.
These theologies are in fact heretical in nature. It may sound right for a person without background knowledge on Orthodoxy.
These are heretical because, in Orthodoxy (which predates Augustinian and Anselmian heresies), one will never find not only any conciliar preference about Original Sin and Satisfaction Theory of Atonement but also ANY Biblical reference for what these claim.
THE ORTHODOX CHRISTIAN VIEW AS HELD BY HOLY TRADITION AND HOLY SCRIPTURES
“Sin spread to all men because all men sinned” (Romans 5:12); and in sinning man brought death to the children who partake of his mortal nature and life. In a sin-bound world, no person escapes, even those who are personally guiltless and innocent, for all are caught up in the sins of the world. (2)
(The verse talks about how THROUGH sin, DEATH entered the world. So the unnatural state of dying, both physical and spiritual, is what WE inherited from Adam and Eve. We DID NOT inherit Adam and Eve's SIN AND GUILT.)
Genesis 3 and Romans 5:12-21 shows us that: Death is the result of sin. It is the final victory of the devil, the result of his destructive activity. If man had not sinned, he would not have died. His body may have changed and evolved over great periods of time, but it would not have been separated from his spirit to return to the dust, And man’s soul itself would not have been corrupted, losing power over its body and becoming its slave. This is the meaning of the sin of Adam, that man has emerged on the face of the earth, made in God’s image and inspired with His Spirit, and has chosen death instead of life, evil instead of righteousness, and so through defilement of his nature in rebellion against God, brought corruption and death to the world. (3)
THUS contrary to Western Theology, Orthodox Christianity (The genuine Christianity) with her Holy Traditions and Holy Scriptures, do not teach the Original Sin and Satisfaction Theory of Atonement. The Orthodox Church views SIN not as something that "offended" God's sensibilities. SIN is more like "missing the target", an illness that needs the most correct cure. Humans were created essentially GOOD, (I think the Creation Story is pretty much detailed about it.) and in Communion with God. But when sin entered the world, humans goodness was not totally lost, but marred, by being separate from God. The human goodness was marred but not defaced or destroyed. Here, God is not an angry deity that needs appeasement. It is through His mercy that He banished our first parents so that they would not become immortal in sin (in Orthodox Theology, we had immortality, so had Adam and Eve not banished from Eden, we would ALL BECOME IMMORTAL IN SIN.). Thus, when SIN ENTERED THE WORLD they became MORTALS. Now, we are destined to die a physical death, and if we are not in communion with God through Christ, spiritual death is what we will have. As it is stated in Matthew 10:28 "...fear Him who is able to destroy both soul and body in hell." (ellipsis, mine)
Therefore, what we inherited from Adam and Eve were not their personal sin and guilt, but DEATH. Since Death IS THE RESULT OF SIN. In Orthodoxy, death IS unnatural, since in the first PERFECT state with God there was NO DEATH to speak of.
HERE NOW is the second matter: The Salvation Plan.
Contrary to the Atheistic claims that Christianity is desperate for death, in fact, Christianity IS THE ONLY world view that actually gives humans leeway from death!
Satan is not only the father of lies, he is also steeped in jealousy. He is jealous of human beings. In the Bible, humans are more loved by God than His angels! This fact is what amazes me... And what disgusts Satan... So when sin entered the world, so did Death. But the moment Satan and Death entered, Almighty God, sentenced Satan and Death to eternal death by having The Woman's Seed crush the serpent's head by His heel.
As one Orthodox psalm says "having trampled Death BY DEATH..." It is through the voluntary act of The Son that Death IS NOW finally destroyed. That in Him, we shall have eternal life: not just spirits walking around, but with our resurrected bodies, fully in awareness and in Communion with God. As scriptures say:
For this reason the Father loves me, because I lay down my life that I may take it again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have the power to lay it down, and I have the power to take it again; this charge I have received from my Father. (John 10:17-18)
Clearly the verse above doesn't talk about an angry deity who needs appeasement by killing his own son so he can make peace with his enemies.
Now is my soul troubled. And what shall I say? “Father, save me from this hour?” No, for this purpose I have come to this hour.
Now is the judgment of the world, now shall the prince of the world be cast out; and 1, when I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all men to my- self. He said this to show by what death He was to die (i.e. crucifixion).
The crowd answered Him, “We have heard from the law that the Christ (i.e. Messiah) remains forever. How can you say that the Son of Man must be lifted up? Who is this Son of Man?”
Jesus said to them, “The light is with you for a little longer…” (John 12:27-35, cf. Matthew 16:21-23, 17:9-13)
Jesus came “for us men and for our salvation” in order to die. (Nicene Creed) He came that through His death and resurrection all men might be raised from the dead for eternal life in the Kingdom of God. This is the Christian faith.
(HERE I think atheists need to take a double look at Christianity before saying WE ARE PRO-DEATH. Consider the following verses:)
...for the hour is coming when all who are in the graves will hear the voice of the Son of God, and come forth, for those who have done good, to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil, to the resurrection of damnation. (John 5:25-29)
This, too, is the apostle’s doctrine. (cf. Acts 2:22-36)
But in fact Christ has been raised from the dead, the first fruits of those who have fallen asleep. For as by a man came death, by a man has come also the resurrection of the dead. For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ shall all be made alive. But each in his own order: Christ the first fruits, then at His coming those who belong to Christ. Then comes the end, when He delivers the kingdom to God the Father after destroying every rule and every authority and power. For He must reign until He has put all His enemies under His feet. The last enemy to be destroyed is death. (I Corinthians 15:20-26)
For the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable, and we shall be changed. For this perishable nature must put on the imperishable, and this mortal nature must put on immortality. When the perishable puts on the imperishable, and the mortal puts on immortality, then shall come to pass the saying that is written:
“Death is swallowed up in victory.
O death, where is thy victory?
O death, where is thy sting?”
The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. But thanks be to God, who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ. (I Corinthians 15:52-57) (4)
CONCLUSION
The bottom-line of this blog post are the following:
1. Atheism is rebellion against Western Theology. Atheists want to disprove God but really, their attacks are against heretic claims that humans are totally depraved and that Christians (allegedly) want this world to end so badly because of that.
2. IN CHRIST WE ARE NOT DOOMED TO EXTINCTION. There is an afterlife. But it's on how we respond to God's call for repentance and communion with Him that we are saved for Eternity. Physical death IS NOT THE END OF LIFE.
3. If there are persons pro-death here, these are the Atheists. By denying God because of hatred (hating the "western god" anyway), they have also denied the glaring fact that this world can become a better place, in this life and the next. It's the twisted minds who reduce the world to nothing but material, no matter how noble their writings sound, who are promoting that this life should never have meaning at all. Because after all, we are just dancing in our DNA's music...
4. The Bible is uncompromising when it says "FOR GOD SO LOVED THE WORLD THAT HE GAVE HIS ONLY BEGOTTEN SON THAT WHOSOEVER BELIEVES IN HIM WILL NOT PERISH BUT HAVE EVERLASTING LIFE." John 3:16. The God of the Christians is so involved in human life that He sent His Son to trample down death by Death (on the Cross) so all who will look upon Him will have everlasting life (The Resurrection)
4. Atheists should be thankful that despite of what they believe, this salvation is available for them also.
***
So one must never be so proud. We all are going back to dust. But through God's love, we will be able to live with Him in eternity. This is how much God loves LIFE. And we Orthodox must do the same. We must love life to it's fullness here on earth by doing God's will AS IT IS IN HEAVEN.
Through the prayers of your most pure Mother, SAVIOR SAVE US!
FIN
Footnotes: